Thursday, November 05, 2009

REV: Sigma Karma Pro Headlight

I’ve been riding the Karma for far too long not to have written it up. Apologies, Sigma.

The short version: Nice work indeed. This style of light is the way of the future for commuting, and I enthusiastically endorse it.

Longer Review: Sigma has been known in the US market for their durable bike computers with manuals containing quirky German-to-English translation. They’ve also had a wide range of lights, but it seems like recently a new designer stepped up to the plate. The Karma was my first experience.



Images of the light alone don’t do its size, or lack thereof, justice. Both the emitter and battery are TINY. Together, they weigh only (have to dig out my gram scale.)

The lithium-ion battery pack combined with the efficiency of a regulated LED is great. The light lasts about 4 hours on high, as claimed and tested by yours truly. At the end of my four-hour, round trip, commute, burning on high, the Karma JUST began to run out of batteries. On “economy” mode, Sigma claims sixteen hours, but I was not about to test that! The new model features a flashing mode as well, but my demo was not so equipped.

An excellent balance between weight, brightness, and battery life, the Karma is designed as a commuter light.

Just how bright is 75 Lux? Rating lighting systems against one another is challenging. Sigma use “LUX” to rate their lights, Light and Motion counts Lumens, and Cateye shows rankings in Candlepower. Without getting into physics, I will say that the Karma is quite bright, but not “portable sun” bright.

The beam is quite narrow; it will illuminate your lane, but will not light up the lane beside you. The Karma feels designed as a helmet-mounted light, which works for me, as it allows you to announce your presence to automobile cross-traffic.

For backroads in complete darkness, I found myself wanting a little more light. Sigma offers a high-quality, waterproof splitter cable that lets you run a pair of lights off a single battery. Now, I'm guessing it was intended for handlebars, but, I ended up with frog eyes!




With both lights on high, flying down Peasley Canyon way at thirty-five miles an hour, I’m not outrunning my lights, and reflective surfaces on both sides of the road flare up at me. The single battery still lasts more than my whole commute, and if I needed to recharge at the office, the included rapid-smart-charger brings a dead battery to full charge in about two hours.

This is a far cry from the overnight-recharges and ninety-minute run time of NiCd Halogen lights of the past!

Fit and finish are great, and includes lots of little tricks: it includes both a helmet mount and a fairly tricky handlebar mount that ratchets on with a single pinch. The emitter shell is a machined aluminum cylinder, and the power button is fully sealed – it’s about as watertight as a sport wristwatch. That’s essential for commuting in the Pacific Northwest.

Also included is a multi-directional quick release battery mount that affixes to your handlebar, stem, top tube, or helmet. The battery is light enough that it’s not uncomfortable on the back of my helmet, or you can use the included extension cable and drop the battery in a jersey pocket.

Sigma is also standardizing their batteries across their range, and the L-ION packs
can be used with a number of other lights. It’s nice not have to play the “which battery goes with which light?” game, or carry multiple chargers with you to races or events.

Disadvantages? The on-off switch is a little quirky. To activate the light, you double-click the switch. Single clicks cycle through the high-low-economy-flashing modes, but will not return the light to “off”; this requires a press and hold for two seconds. I’d rather have the option of a squeeze bulb on the extension cord to activate the light. With two on my helmet, I find myself fumbling with soaked gloves or cold fingers to adjust both lights.

Of course, most rides will be shorter than the total battery life for most riders, so you’d just pick your desired brightness at the start and turn it off at the end.
I like the quick-release handlebar mount, but today’s bikes are coming with an increasingly strange array of handlebar sizes, so I’d like to see a “mountless” O-ring option for the light on bars – this works quite well with lightweight emitters like the Karma, and Sigma use a similar setup for their tail lights.

Summary : With light weight, long battery life, and water tightness, the Karma is an excellent choice for commuters who want to step up from Alkaline-powered lights. Alone or in tandem, it could make a good night-riding light, but more firepower might be necessary for 24-hour mountain bike racing.

Addendum No, I'm not going to take the light out in the dark and attempt to take a picture to show how much illumination it produces. That shows more about the camera than it does about the light...

Tuesday, June 30, 2009

Cateye Compact Safety Lights ; Airborne Mini-Pump



How many lights and tire pumps can one reviewer test? I’m about to find out.

For starters, let me say that these Cateye Compact Safety Lights make a great little party game. The trick goes like this: Hand out the little yo-yo looking things to your friends. Challenge them to turn them on. Hillarity ensues.

The only instructions I found suggested that they had a "unique magnetic switch." Okay, fine, but where the heck is the switch? I gave up and begged for help. That little tab at the end of the lanyard there -- it's a magnet. Lightly tap it to the center of the light body, and you get two tiny LED's on steady, blinking together, or blinking in alternation.

The good news is that they're impressively versatile. You can mount them on anything, no tools, just a few seconds -- this includes both seatposts bits of your bike, but also on wrists, ankles, backpacks, whatever. The magnetic switch also means that they fully seal with their little gasket. They're supposed to be as waterproof as your digital watch. You can keep a pair on your jersey pocket or bag and if you end up caught out at dusk, you're covered.

Bad news, though, is that they're really not very bright. I don't have exciting numbers about lumens and such to compare them with, but certainly they are a far cry from the half-watt LED's like Princeton Tec's Swerve and Planet Bike's Superflash that have become the new standard. They're probably about as noticable as those little cheapo single LED blinkies, and far easier to mount. Their CR2032 batteries will probably last quite a bit longer, though you'll be out a few more pennies when they do go. Make sure you hit up dealextreme for spares!

While they cost a couple of bucks more than the generic double-or-triple-A-powered taillights, you don't have to worry about swapping them between all of your bikes, buying a million mounts, losing stuff, or having them stolen at the cafe, so that's a plus. I'll bet you could skip them like a stone across the pond, too, and they would keep blinking on the way down. Maybe we'll use them for diving practice?

---

Airborne's mini pump is pretty slick. We're awash in fairly standard mini pumps, and as I've told you before, using one is a ridiculous, aggravating experience for Yours Truly. I previously showed you Leyne's redux on a classic solution to the problem. Here is Airborne's.

This thing is tiny, and fits easily into a jersey pocket. It also includes a little bottle-cage mount if you'd prefer. If you've ever tried to use other mini pumps its size, you'll know that they're barely able to get you home. This little sucker is light and well-constructed, with a tightly fitting barrel over a machined aluminum sleeve.

The Airborne is small but fully functional: check out the rotating chuck. You actually thread that onto the valve stem, and the main body of the pump serves as the handle. This creates an absolutely tiny amount of air per stroke, but I was able to put it to better use than the Blackburn Airstik I’ve used as my benchmark minipump. I can’t manage not to waste a significant portion of the air with any non-sealing pump, so perhaps more precise readers do better. Also, there’s no double-valving on the Airborne pump, so you’re only moving air on the downstroke, the upstroke just takes up time.

Again, this isn’t the fastest procedure, but I still had 90 PSI or so, my usual riding pressure, in a couple of minutes, and without making the veins in my forehead blow out. All that it took was a little patience.

One possibly major caveat : unlike the Lezyne system, which threads onto the very small collar just below the Presta valve, the Airborne pump threads onto the main body of the valve stem itself. This is less likely to break or bend the valve at strange angles, but absolutely requires a threaded valve stem to work. If you have a smooth stem – some of mine are -- then you are up a creek. You cannot in any way inflate a smooth-stemmed tube, the threading is required to seal it.

I also found I cannot use the pump on the non-threaded valve extender I use on a set of deep-section wheels. I don't want to have to do is decide if the spare tubes and pump that I’m carrying are compatible! If your favorite tube brand has threading, though: it doesn’t weigh any more than a 16gm inflator and even the lightest head, and it reliably gets up to working pressure.

I won't even get into the "should you carry CO2, a mini pump, or both," debate, except to say that they let me carry my arms on the plane with me to San Francisco last weekend. They let me bring this pump, too.

Friday, May 22, 2009

Product Test - Avenir Woodsie Tools



The cycling world is awash in multitools, Swiss army-like bundles of hex wrenches carried about by cyclists for on-the-fly adjustments and repairs. The Avenir Woodsie tools, available in 8-, 10-, and 11-function versions. A dollar or two more expensive than the Trail Tech series of basic tools, the Woodsies add a touch of style with real wood panels. Unfortunately, they're not as stylish as this Woodie:



The eight-function tool has all of the basic cyclists' needs -- hex keys in 2, 2.5, 3, 4, 5, and 6mm hex wrenches, plus phillips and flathead screwdrivers. I've got no idea what on a bike takes a flathead screw, but I've had some 2.5mm adjustment bolts on random bits that frustrated me when all I had was a 2 and a 3! Realistically, 90% of fasteners on a modern bicycle are 4, 5, or 6mm.

The Woodsie 10 adds an 8mm hex wrench and a t-25 torx. If you've got a SRAM / Truvativ GXP crank, let me tell you from personal experience -- keep an 8mm wrench on you at all times. That single crankbolt is the key to the whole system. If it works its way loose on a harsh ride, you'll irreparably damage your crankset. As for the T-25 torx wrench, this roadie isn't sure where it's useful, since those Shimano chainring bolts need a T30.

Really, though, you should pay the extra couple clams for the 11-function tool, which adds a chain breaker. If you ever hopelessly garble your chain, this plus a Wipperman or SRAM masterlink will get you back on the road full speed, without resorting to the walk of shame in your cycling cleats! It's actually a fairly useful chaintool for a pocket one, with a flip-out lever to give you the extra torque you need for a feisty, gunky chain.



Some super fancypants multitools give you knives, pliers, and kitchen sinks, but, really, this is what you need without what you don't. Except the wood panels -- those are just neat.

One quick word to the wise -- refolding that chain tool is a bit of an origami game. I get best results opening the hex wrenches, folding the chain tool first, and then refolding the whole deal. The extra-leverage arm for the chain tool is curved to fit snugly against the rest of the tools.

Thursday, May 21, 2009

Brief Product Test -- Mirrcycle STI mirror and bell

I'm going to admit from the beginning that I'm not a big fan of mirrors on bicycles. I just don't think they provide any information that I need to know. Auto-bicycle accidents in which both vehicles are going in the same direction are rare, and I'd rather be focusing on the road in front of me. A small mirror wouldn't eliminate the need for a head-check before lane changes in any case.

Regardless of that, if you DO want to have a mirror on your road bicycle, your options are somewhat limited. Normal bar-mount mirrors can't usually be installed in a useful position. Bar end mirrors end up at an extreme enough angle that you've got to lean your head down pretty far to see more than your armpit in them.

You install these by peeling back the hoods on STI levers, and using a tiny 2mm hex bolt and nut to clamp the mirror on the plastic tab that once held the hood. I tried them on my 9-speed shifters, and believe they work the same on 7- and 8-speed STI's, as well as the both styles of 10-speed system. This is both novel and fairly secure.

I took it on my 64-mile round trip commute, on a combination of MUT's and some of Tacoma's nastiest chip-and-seal, pothole-strewn, tar-over-cobblestone roads. On anything but smooth roads, it's just not stable enough. Vibrations shake it enough that you cannot clearly see what is behind you, and even with the adjustment bolts cranked well down, the mirror still tips forward. It needs to have stronger "teeth" and some kind of dampener to be useful.

Also, while the hood-mounting tab makes a convenient mounting place for a mirror, it means that your STI hood is not properly installed at any point. When climbing up 58th, a twisty single-lane road, the hoods began to slip about the levers, since they were not securely engaged.

In conclusion, I don't think these are a great idea for most serious roadies, whether commuters or training. For those who ride mostly on trails and cyclepaths, or for folks who have a hard time with flexibility in turning their head quickly, they might be worth considering.

I found the STI-mounted bell a little easier to cope with. It's small enough that it doesn't interfere with the hood as much as the mirror, and it puts the flick lever to ring the bell right at your thumb. Ding!

I've never ridden with a bell, either. I quickly learn that most joggers cannot hear bells over ipods, many young children like to veer into your path when they hear the ring, and occasional old dudes cruising along on their comfort bikes will smile and wave you by. Ding!

Okay, I took the thing off. Think of the aerodynamic losses! Okay, maybe not, but I couldn't put my hands as smoothly as on the hoods as I could before I installed the bell.

Still, if you're the type to have a bell, and you have a road bike, these seem to work pretty well. Ding!

Friday, May 15, 2009

Happy Bike to Work Day!

I told you May is Bike to work month, and, within that, today we're celebrating bike to work DAY.

In that spirit, Raleigh and Diamondback are out on the trail, handing out schwag to all comers:



Matt and Paul, Avenir Parts and Accessories Extraordinaires, handing out coffee and Clif bars!



The bike garage is more full than usual today...



And here's Monette and Alexander, cooking up a delicious storm. Thanks!

Friday, March 13, 2009

First Ride -- Shimano 7970 Di2



Electric. Shifters.

This has been tried before, you're right, but I'm too new to the sport to remember all of that Mektronic business.

So, when I see the blueshirts pull out a LaPierre with a funky-looking brick behind the front derailleur, I had to go investigate. Yes, that's Alex, with this prototype of the mouthful that Shimano calls "Dura Ace 7970 Di2." It's for real this time, ladies and gentlemen. Both Big S and Campagnolo have been developing electric groups for the past several years, but Shimano bit the bullet first and put theirs on the market.

On sale soon at a high-end bicycle shop near you, Di2 will cost you something like $3,000 for the basic 4-piece group -- that's STI shifters, both derailleurs, plus a battery and charger. On top of that, you'll need a crank, chain, and brakes, which Shimano STRONGLY recommends using Dura-Ace 7900 parts for. Expect bikes with this complete group to cost 5-figure amounts without too much trouble.

What do you get for that kind of coin? What's the benefit?

The short version is this: The front derailleur is effortless and perfect.

A few years ago, I did one of my first races, on a rolling course near Bellingham, WA, and I had it in my gung-ho mind that I was going to attack at a certain portion of the course. We were starting a big climb, and a guy a couple of rows in front of me started to accelerate, and I shifted into my big ring to go over the top.

Except, that's not what I did. Instead, I slowed too much and powered the chain over the side of the big ring. I wasn't slick enough to get it going before my rapidly diminishing momentum faded, so I had to climb off, throw the chain back on, and chase. I had the same level of suffering, but rather than off the front of the pack, I was off the back chasing.

All commentary about my skill notwithstanding, this would not have happened on Di2. The front derailleur is the most complicated part of this system, and as far as I could tell simply could not drop the chain. Seriously, this thing has laser alignment. Lasers, folks!



Even my two laps around the parking lot showed me the magic, and unbiased sources confirm it’s the same under full load up a gnarly hill. You can still shift.

We had a technical Q&A session with the Shimano dudes, and I asked them everything I could think of that would foul this up. Of course, everyone asks how long a charge of the battery lasts, and it’s not like a light where you recharge the thing daily. One zap a week ought to be fine. If you lose, wear out, or destroy yours, it’s also the only part of the system that “does not say Dura-Ace on it,” meaning it’s produced under contract, carries a 1-year warranty, and costs a relatively reasonable $99.99.

How about fitting the battery to smaller frames? Sure, you get a bottle-cage lifter that allows you that flexibility, and Alex said they had also gotten several other positions on the seat tube area to work fine.

What if the computer goes wonky on you? It won’t, but if you don’t believe me, you can hit this control button on your bars, and recalibrate the thing if you like.

Want to run your front shifter on your right hand? Can do.

What if you crash that $900 rear derailleur? Well, of course, it’s not indestructible, but the derailleur senses impact and retracts to the top of the cogs, making at least, um, crash-resistant.

Now, how about if you’re installing the wiring, or putting the bike on the car, and you cut the wiring harness? That, sir, is a $300 mistake you’ll only make once. Still, I wish they’d found a way to make the wiring harness more affordable. Shimano replied that perhaps as quantities went up, price would go down some, but they also advised that compatible frames will be able to run the wires completely internally, minimizing chances of damage.

As a guy who has loaded his bike into a van with 20 other bikes countless times, I’d be more than a little concerned about that one! Wireless is a no-go at least for now, though, because of higher battery drain and risk of cross-talk in the peloton causing exciting things to happen.

When riding the stuff, the way that you really notice that you’re riding electric is the mouse-click effort required to shift. On the front, this is a really big deal – no more high effort, long-travel sweep while trying to climb. The rear doesn’t feature a multiple shift feature, but you can rattle ‘em off as fast as you can touch the button. Automatic trim on the front derailleur means one can run fully cross-chained as much as you like, though I suppose it’d wear the chain faster.

Instead of thwacking, rifle-bolt shift sounds, the rear derailleur makes a quick “zzzzziiip,” like pulling down a zipper quickly. It feels more natural than I expected, though I mistakenly tried to move the brake lever to shift, like all other Shimano designs. On Di2, the shifters are both small buttons behind the brake levers, which only operate the brakes.

Two laps around the lot, and several chances to make Di2 foul up a shift all failed. It’s solid stuff.

In short, will I buy it? Right now, probably not.

Cost notwithstanding, though, given the choice, would I race on Di2? Absolutely. No questions asked.

That’s pretty impressive.

Friday, February 13, 2009

Raleigh Clubman Initial Review:



I picked up my '09 Raleigh Clubman last week, and have been rolling out the miles on it since.

The Clubman, new for '09, is the Swiss Army knife of road bikes -- it's got a tool for everything, even if you have to kind of fight with the screwdriver to get some things done.

Some entry-level bicycles use steel frames just for price, but there's a big difference between basic "Hi-ten" steel and nice 4130 Chromo tubing. Of course, the Clubman will never be an ultralight bike, but its 25-pound-ish weight disappears beneath the quality of the ride. Steel also means braze-ons not seen as frequently on modern road bikes: it's got a pump peg, chain holder, and rear rack mount. There's also fender mounts, two pairs of bottle cage bosses and a drilled chainstay bridge.

Picking up where the One-Way left off and growing into a multispeed bicycle, the steel frame and lugged steel fork appear traditional. Classic, understated styling is a nice contrast to the over-stickered, shout-it-from-the-rooftops branding so common on today’s bikes. The slightly sloping top tube gives the modernity of the Clubman away, and will of course be a controversial styling element.

Timeless leather Brooks Swift saddle is a hit with everyone who looks at it, and contrasts again with the modern, compact Shimano Tiagra drivetrain and black Avenir 200-series cockpit. I’m of mixed opinion about about the brown bar tape over wing-topped bars.

There's enough clearance for 700 x 27c tires with full fenders, a big contrast to the tight spaces in race-style modern road bikes, or 700 x 32c's without fenders. Long-reach brake calipers can handle these combinations, too, and if you feel like going single or fixed, it’s a can-do with the horizontal, forward-facing dropouts.

There’s also a traditional, pressed in headset on a slightly extended headtube, so you can drop that King in and ride your bars and saddle level without a riser stem. A few retro-grouches have complained that it’s still got a threadless headset, but, with all due respect – it’s time to move on. If you feel like backing down the technology, though, feel free to replace your STI’s with downtube shifters – bosses are included.

With skinny tires, the Clubman is a fast bike, accelerating nicely over small rises and rolling hills. It keeps up just fine on the single, ahem, club ride I’ve taken it on. On 32’s, it’s nearly a cyclocross bike, though the lack of clearance between caliper and tire means I wouldn’t use it for CX racing. Bring on the fire roads! 73 degree head and seat angles along with slightly elongated chainstays create predictable, neutral handling, though I haven’t pushed it to its limits in the twisties.

I barely notice I’m riding the Clubman. It feels complimentary and springy when I accelerate, smooth and relaxed when I cruise, and the nastiest parts of the horrid Tacoma pavement are ironed over, even if it cannot be run like a tank through all obstacles like the Sojourn could.

Modern categories would struggle to define the Clubman – far more affordable than a custom, bespoke steel bike but heavier than a pure race bike of similar price, the Clubman is the bike you’ll WISH you had bought. It’s not a ‘cross bike, not a touring bike, not a commuter bike, not a race bike; instead, the Clubman is just a bike.

Now go ride one.






Notes: Yes, careful observer, I did swap the bars out on my bike. I know some riders who are entirely tied to wing-style handlebars, and others who utterly refuse them. I don't find they fit my hand style, but it's a personal preference. Likewise, I think that a classic, round-bend bar would really set off this bike, but I've been using this style of Ritchey drop for a few years, and for some reason it just works for me.

Also, the Clubman does include a Lezyne pump, just like the Sojourn does. Thirty bucks at retail, and they work quite well, even if that means you won't need to use that pump peg -- See my review here.